Most owners know Google has rules about reviews. Fewer know the ACCC has a view too, and it's broader. Google's rules cover reviews on Google. Australian consumer law covers reviews wherever you show them: your website, your Facebook page, a printed menu, the testimonials slider on your homepage.
The good news is that the basics are common sense. Here's what the ACCC expects, in plain English.
Why this is separate from Google's rules
If you've read our guide to what Google's policies allow, you've seen the Google side. This is the other half. The ACCC's concern is simple: reviews influence what people buy, so reviews that mislead people are a problem, whoever publishes them.
That means the rules follow your business, not the platform. A café owner showing "our best reviews" on a window poster and a mechanic quoting customers on their website are both covered by the same ideas.
1. Don't write or arrange fake reviews
The ACCC's position is blunt: it's against the law for a business to create fake or misleading reviews, or to arrange for others to do so.
Fake doesn't only mean invented. The ACCC also points to reviews from family, employees or people paid by the business that don't say how they're connected to it, and reviews from people who never used the product or service. A physio's cousin posting five stars, or a salon team all reviewing the same week, can mislead even if everyone means well.
The fix is easy. Ask real customers who really used you. With reviews from staff or relatives, the ACCC's concern is the connection that isn't stated. Google is stricter: its policy treats a review from someone with a work or family tie to the business as a conflict of interest, and those reviews aren't allowed. So keep staff and family reviews off your Google profile altogether.
2. If you offer something for a review, the rules are tighter
Say you run a sale for anyone who leaves a review, or enter reviewers into a draw. The ACCC says incentives like that risk misleading people. If you offer one at all, it has to be offered whether the review is positive or negative, and it has to be clearly disclosed so readers know the review was incentivised.
Now the useful contrast. For Google reviews, Google goes further and doesn't allow incentives at all. So even an incentive that meets the ACCC's conditions isn't an option on Google. For reviews there, the safe answer is simple: ask, say thanks, and don't reward. Our post on what Google's policies allow has the detail.
3. Don't hide, edit or cherry-pick
This is the one that surprises people. Showing only your five-star reviews on your own website, quietly removing a genuine bad one, or tidying up the wording of a review can mislead readers about what customers really think.
The ACCC has taken action on this. In the HealthEngine case, the ACCC says the business admitted it hadn't published many negative reviews and had edited others to remove the negative parts, and the Federal Court ordered penalties, including for the misleading reviews.
A few practical points:
- If you show reviews on your own site, show the real picture. Our suggestion: if you feature a handful, say that's what they are, so nobody takes them for the full set.
- Never change the words of a review. The ACCC warns that a review edited by someone else after it was written can mislead. Our suggestion: quote it as written, and if you only have room for part of it, make it clear it's an extract.
- Show the number of reviews with the rating. "4.8 from 112 reviews" tells people more than "4.8" does.
4. Unfair or fake reviews about you
What if the shoe is on the other foot, and someone posts a review that's clearly fake or unfair? You have options: report it to the platform, and reply publicly, calmly. The ACCC also cautions that before you remove or edit a review, you should have a good basis for believing it's fake or misleading. Taking down a genuine negative review can itself mislead people.
We've covered the practical steps in Fake and unfair Google reviews: what you can actually do, so we won't repeat them here.
5. Testimonials on your own website
Testimonials count as reviews. The same ideas apply: they should be real, from real customers, and not altered in a way that changes what they say. An accountant's "what clients say" page, a clinic's website or a trade business's portfolio all fit here.
Health practitioners have extra rules about testimonials in advertising. One sentence is enough here: see AHPRA and Google reviews if that's you. And since reviews often include names and details, privacy law is worth a look before you reproduce anything.
A simple checklist
- Every review on my profile and website comes from a real customer who used us.
- Reviews from family, employees or anyone paid by the business are not on Google, and are clearly labelled anywhere else.
- I don't reward Google reviews, and any other incentive is offered whatever the rating, and disclosed.
- I haven't deleted, edited or hidden genuine reviews just because they're negative.
- My ratings show how many reviews they're based on.
- If I remove or dispute a review, I have a good reason to think it's fake.
If you can tick all six, you're in good shape.
Where Gold Reviews fits
Gold Reviews sends every customer the same review request, whatever their experience, and never filters who gets asked. Each customer chooses whether to leave a Google review or share private feedback with you. Gold Reviews doesn't edit or remove reviews. See how it works.
Ten founding spots are open at $29 a month, locked in while you stay subscribed, with everything in the Growth plan.
Same request, same choice for every customer
Gold Reviews sends every customer the same review request, whatever their experience, and never filters who gets asked.
Claim your founding spot →$29/mo, locked in while you stay subscribed · 14-day free trial when your spot opens · No lock-in contract
This is general information, not legal advice. For your own situation, speak to a lawyer, and check the ACCC's guidance on online reviews for the latest.